Call Us Freephone:

03335 77 66 55

Opening Hours:

Mon–Fri 9:00am to 5:00pm

TrustMark Consultation 2026

Competence, Records and Transparency

Competence must be demonstrated, and evidence must follow the property

An accreditation badge, training attendance certificate or company registration does not necessarily establish that every individual undertaking a specialist task has been properly assessed as competent.

OSCAR believes the quality assurance system must distinguish between business registration, individual occupational competence, technical supervision and independent verification.

Competence across the entire process

Different stages of an insulation project require different knowledge and practical abilities.

These can include:

A person competent in one occupation should not automatically be assumed competent in all the others.

OSCAR’s approach to occupational competence

OSCAR’s experience includes developing cavity wall insulation awareness training, specialist extraction accreditation, inspection processes and technical monitoring arrangements.

Its approach places emphasis on the practical requirements of the work rather than relying solely on generic business membership.

For specialist cavity wall insulation extraction, OSCAR’s accreditation model identifies the individuals involved and requires appropriate individual certification.

Company accreditation and individual operative competence serve different purposes.

This distinction should be reflected across the wider industry.

Training must be meaningful

OSCAR believes competence arrangements should examine:

An online training course can contribute to knowledge, but course attendance alone should not be represented as proof of every practical competence required for specialist work.

Accreditation claims must be accurate

A company may hold recognition for a particular trade or activity without being accredited for every service advertised on its website.

OSCAR advocates auditing the relationship between:

Misleading or overstated accreditation claims should be corrected through clear and proportionate processes.

The property evidence record

OSCAR proposes that relevant information should follow the property throughout the lifecycle of an energy-efficiency measure.

This could include:

Before installation

  • Assessment and suitability findings.
  • Construction type.
  • Specification and design.
  • Existing condition photographs.
  • Product/system identification.

During installation

  • Contractor and operative identities.
  • Competence and registration details.
  • Dates of work.
  • Installation records.
  • Inspection and monitoring evidence.

After installation

  • Completion documentation.
  • Guarantees.
  • Handover information.
  • Relevant performance evidence.

If a problem arises

  • Complaint history.
  • Independent survey findings.
  • Technical decisions.
  • Remedial specifications.
  • Extraction and waste records.
  • Clearance verification.
  • Reinstatement records.
  • Claim outcomes.

This information should remain accessible to authorised parties even where the original contractor ceases trading.

Access must be appropriately controlled and comply with applicable data protection requirements.

Auditing must examine real work

A successful quality assurance regime cannot rely solely on uploaded paperwork.

OSCAR supports risk-based checks that examine actual site outcomes, including evidence of defects, recurring complaints, incomplete remediation and inconsistencies between declared and observed work.

The system should also provide fair procedures for registered businesses and individuals, including correction of inaccurate records and independent review of disputed technical decisions.

OSCAR’s proposed improvements

  • Published occupation-specific competence requirements.
  • Verification of training and practical capability.
  • Scrutiny of accreditation and certification bodies.
  • Accurate public descriptions of accreditation scope.
  • Individual accountability without unjustified transfer of company liabilities.
  • A lasting, secure property evidence record.
  • Risk-based site auditing.
  • Independent technical review.
  • Transparent responsibility for complaints, decisions and remedies.

Consumer confidence should rest on demonstrable competence, traceable evidence and independently verifiable outcomes—not on a logo alone.

Explore OSCAR’s TrustMark Consultation Response

This subject forms part of OSCAR Onsite Ltd’s wider response to the TrustMark consultation on strengthening consumer protection.

Back to all six topics

The views and recommendations expressed are those of OSCAR Onsite Ltd and should not be interpreted as decisions, endorsements or accepted proposals of TrustMark.

Explore other topics